
FDA Vaping Regulation Postponed – Is The Tide Shifting?
In late July 2017, FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb announced a comprehensive plan for tobacco and nicotine regulation that surprised much of the vaping industry. Under the plan, e-cigarette makers would have until August 8, 2022 to submit Premarket Tobacco Applications (PMTAs), instead of facing the earlier 2018 deadline.
The plan also shifted the FDA's attention toward traditional cigarettes.
Update: The 2022 deadline did not hold. Under a federal court order, makers of e-cigarettes on the market as of August 8, 2016 had to submit applications by September 9, 2020. FDA has since denied or refused applications for millions of products, and only a short list of authorized e-cigarettes may be lawfully sold in the US.
FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb said in an FDA press release:
Envisioning a world where cigarettes would no longer create or sustain addiction, and where adults who still need or want nicotine could get it from alternative and less harmful sources, needs to be the cornerstone of our efforts.
Many in the vaping community saw this change in tone as a major victory. Some said Gottlieb may have just saved the American vaping industry, though it was too early to say that at the time.
* Read additional remarks from FDA commissioner Scott Gottlieb here
The Fight to Regulate E-Cigs
Before May 2016, the e-cigarette market had almost no federal oversight. Entrepreneurs were opening retail stores, designing new products, crafting their own e-juice flavors and the vaping industry was booming. In May 2016, the FDA finalized its deeming rule, which took effect August 8, 2016 and brought electronic cigarettes and e-liquids under its authority. Premarket review deadlines were set to start in 2018.
The rules imposed an extensive, expensive and lengthy approval process before a product could stay on or come to market, which many expected to shrink the vaping industry sharply. In particular, e-liquid manufacturers, many of which are small independent startups and not part of the tobacco lobby, would be forced to close their doors with application costs running into the millions.
The irony is that in an effort to safeguard public health, the FDA was discouraging a proven, less risky alternative than tobacco. Advocates argued that Multiple studies have proven e-cigarettes help adult smokers quit and are considerably less harmful than smoking. A Cochrane review later found high-certainty evidence that nicotine e-cigarettes help more people quit than nicotine replacement therapy. Still, no e-cigarette has been FDA-approved as a quit-smoking aid.
So the question is, is the FDA’s change of heart a return to common sense e-cig regulations or a step back to reassess and regroup?
A New Focus on Big Tobacco
In addition to temporarily softening its stance on vaping, the FDA refocused on traditional cigarettes, which are proven to harm both smokers and the people around them. Part of the new strategy was to lower nicotine in cigarettes to minimally or non-addictive levels. Objectives outlined by the FDA:
The FDA plans to begin a public dialogue about lowering nicotine levels in combustible cigarettes to non-addictive levels through achievable product standards. The agency intends to issue an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) to seek input on the potential public health benefits and any possible adverse effects of lowering nicotine in cigarettes.
Because almost 90 percent of adult smokers started smoking before the age of 18 and nearly 2,500 youth smoke their first cigarette every day in the U.S., lowering nicotine levels could decrease the likelihood that future generations become addicted to cigarettes and allow more currently addicted smokers to quit.
Are We In The Clear?
Postponing the FDA vaping deadlines was a huge win for the vaping industry at the time. We also supported the FDA’s goal of lowering nicotine levels in cigarettes. But it was too early to claim victory.
Update: On January 15, 2025, the FDA proposed a rule to cap nicotine in cigarettes and most other combusted tobacco at 0.7 milligrams per gram of tobacco. The proposal does not cover e-cigarettes. The FDA still retains federal control over electronic cigarettes and vaping products, so prepare yourself for many battles to come.
At the time, the extension meant that existing products would stay available for several more years while the industry prepared for FDA standards. As the update above shows, that window later closed much sooner than expected.
Sources
- FDA's Comprehensive Plan for Tobacco and Nicotine Regulation, FDA
- FDA Makes Determinations On More Than 99% of the 26 Million Tobacco Products For Which Applications Were Submitted, FDA
- FDA Proposes Significant Step Toward Reducing Nicotine to Minimally or Nonaddictive Level in Cigarettes, FDA
- Can electronic cigarettes help people stop smoking?, Cochrane


