Opposition To Proposed FDA Vaping Regulations Is Strong

Contents

2015 E-Cigarette & Vaping Regulation UpdateThis is a news post from January 2015. See the update below for what happened next.

2015 was expected to be the year e-cigarettes finally came under federal regulation.

Update: The FDA's deeming rule was finalized in May 2016 and took effect on August 8, 2016. Every e-cigarette now needs an FDA marketing order to be sold legally, and the FDA's authorized list contains only a few dozen tobacco- and menthol-flavored products. The federal minimum sales age became 21 on December 20, 2019.

Doctors, government bodies and consumers had called for regulation, both to stabilize the industry and to support research into the long-term health effects of vaping. The FDA’s proposed ‘e-cigarette rules’ were expected to be finalized in 2015, but they drew opposition from both anti-tobacco groups and vaping advocates.

At first glance, the proposals didn’t read too badly. Restricting sales to minors and health warning labels made sense, and were the kinds of measures one would expect from the FDA. So why the opposition?

What Industry Advocates Have to Say

Many smokers had switched to vaping, cutting into tobacco industry sales. Some advocates claimed parts of the proposed rules would favor large tobacco companies.

Gregory Conley, president of the American Vaping Association, argued that the regulations would “work to the benefit of large tobacco and e-cigarette companies” and urged vendors and vapers to oppose them.

Consumer group CASAA (Consumer Advocates for Smoke-free Alternatives Association) also objected to parts of the draft. After its release, CASAA issued this statement:

Yesterday’s FDA draft deeming regulation regarding e-cigarettes, other smoke-free alternatives, and other products is not as bad on its face as it might have been. However, a full review, in the context of background knowledge and institutional analysis, reveals that the proposed regulation is inappropriate, ill-founded, and potentially devastating for consumers. Read more…

CASAA also opposed any tax on vapor products “other than a simple sales tax that consumer products are generally subject to.” The proposals had fueled talk of “sin taxes” that would put e-cigarettes in the same bracket as alcohol and cigarettes.

Several states were weighing bills backing the increased taxation of vapor products at the time. Since then, many states have adopted e-cigarette taxes.

Difficult Environment for Small Companies

Along with proposed sin taxes, CASAA raised concerns about a patchwork of state and local laws on top of the federal rules.

CASAA argued that “too many different state and local laws will make it difficult for products to cross state lines, reducing state access.” Small producers, it said, would struggle to grow beyond their home states.

The most controversial part of the proposal was the “grandfather date.” Any product not on the market by February 15, 2007 would need FDA authorization through a costly premarket application, which covered virtually every e-cigarette.

Under the proposal, companies would have two years after the rule was finalized to submit applications. Products without them would have to come off the market, a huge burden for small manufacturers.

Bill Godshall, executive director of Smokefree Pennsylvania, predicted the rules “would reduce the number of legal e-cig manufacturers from more than a thousand to less than a half dozen.”

Godshall also warned that the rules could feed a black market, sending sales to illegal sellers while big tobacco companies kept the legal market.

What Happened Next

The rule was finalized in 2016, with the February 15, 2007 grandfather date unchanged. Under a federal court order, products already on the market had to submit premarket applications by September 9, 2020.

By March 2023, the FDA had made determinations on more than 99% of nearly 26 million products, issuing denials or refusals for millions. New tobacco products without a marketing order cannot be legally sold in the U.S.

Sources