LA, NY & Chicago Ban E-Cigarette Use in Public – What’s Next?

Contents

City E-Cigarette BansWith the safety of electronic cigarettes in question and comparisons being made to traditional tobacco products, it’s no surprise that politicians have entered into the fray. Sadly, the cliché of ‘just following the money’ leads directly to the offices of many elected officials – and big tobacco and pharmaceutical companies. Politicians have made it their job to protect citizens from real (and imagined) risks and then use taxes and fines to line government coffers, while big tobacco and drug companies happily support these crusades, with the ultimate goal of driving their latest competition, E-CIGARETTES, into the shadows.

E-Cig Bans Already in Place

Not surprisingly, the first areas to jump on the regulation bandwagon have been in places where politicians are quick to decide (and overrule) the will of the people. Chicago and New York are leading the way by adding e-cigarettes to their indoor smoking bans, and Los Angeles is considering the same step. These laws ban vaping where smoking is banned; they don’t ban e-cigarette sales. Their stated intent is to protect people from ‘second-hand-smoke’, which misses the point.

Update: New York City’s rule took effect April 29, 2014. Los Angeles approved its version 14-0 on March 4, 2014, covering restaurants, bars, parks, beaches and workplaces.

Electronic cigarettes DO NOT produce smoke, and most studies on e-cigs thus far have found their vapor far less harmful than cigarette smoke, though not harmless.

A 2012 CleanStream-Air Study put it this way:

…we can conclude by saying that it would be more unhealthy to breath air in a big city than staying in the same room with someone who is vaping.

Smoking is NOT Vaping

E-Cigarette Vs. TobaccoMore than fifty years of research confirms the dangers of smoking. The most recent report by the Surgeon General included a growing list of diseases and debilitating illnesses attributed to cigarettes.

There’s little debate on the negative consequences to both individuals and society from smoking, and although the efforts to curb the number of cigarette smokers is admirable, when it comes to e-cigarettes – IT’S FOOLISH TO LUMP THEM TOGETHER. The vapor of an e-cigarette is significantly less harmful than the chemical-laden smoke from a cigarette. We may not fully understand the long-term impacts yet, but the research suggests that electronic cigarettes are much less harmful for users than tobacco. The NHS says there’s no evidence so far that vaping harms people nearby, but more research is needed.

What is most troubling about the trend to regulate electronic cigarettes and ban them in public places, is that by doing so, these municipalities are providing less incentive for millions of smokers who want to quit. E-cigs expose users to significantly less health risks, and unlike drugs or nicotine replacement therapies such as the patch, they provide the tactile and behavioral stimulation that may increase their chances of kicking the habit. A Cochrane review has since found nicotine e-cigarettes help more people quit than nicotine replacement therapy.

Left out of the equation are the more than 7,000 chemicals in cigarette smoke, at least 69 of which can cause cancer, according to the CDC.

Where is this all heading?

What does the future hold regarding the rights of e-cig users and the nearly $2 billion industry? One thing is certain, because they contain no tobacco, electronic cigarettes fall outside of the jurisdiction of most state laws regulating tobacco products. But that won’t stop the U.S. Congress, FDA and state bureaucrats from coming up with ways to regulate sales, limit advertising, tax or even ban e-cigs.

Update: FDA now regulates e-cigarettes as tobacco products. The federal Tobacco 21 law, signed December 20, 2019, made it illegal to sell any tobacco product, including e-cigarettes, to anyone under 21.

Today only the e-cigarettes on FDA’s authorized list may be lawfully sold in the U.S.

There are a few signs that reason hasn’t completely gone to the dogs. Wisconsin did its homework before tightening tobacco laws in their state and left electronic cigarettes out of the equation after reviewing the science behind vaping. New legislation was introduced in almost every state in 2013, with only nine states enacting laws that impose limited regulations in specific venues like schools and government property. Local jurisdictions have taken their own actions, with more than one hundred counties across the country restricting electronic cigarettes from all smoke-free environments, but this could be quickly overturned (or reassessed) after sweeping state or FDA rules.

Some regulation is not unreasonable…

With 480,000 deaths annually and over $193 billion in healthcare costs associated with smoking each year, it’s a travesty to see electronic cigarettes being smeared by politicians who are misinformed. (That older estimate mixed health care spending and lost productivity; CDC now estimates smoking cost the U.S. more than $600 billion in 2018, including over $240 billion in health care spending.) The public will garner much greater benefits if politicians encourage electronic cigarette use, rather than discourage it. Defining reasonable statutes that keep users safe, without limiting access or their ability to make better choices, makes common sense. Age restrictions are an obvious first step (the federal minimum is now 21), along with full disclosure of ingredients and oversight of the manufacturing process.

If we’re lucky, future legislation will be based on facts and not misinformation or propaganda. We’ve seen the debate shift both ways, but hopefully rational thinking will eventually prevail.

Sources