
E-Cigs Could Save Americans Billions of Dollars in Healthcare Costs
Contents
According to the American Lung Association, smoking is the leading cause of preventable disease and death. When this post was written, the most cited estimate put smoking's annual US cost at about $193 billion, split between lost productivity and direct health care spending.
Update (October 2026): CDC now estimates that cigarette smoking cost the US more than $600 billion in 2018, including more than $240 billion in health care spending.
Smoking is linked to lung disease, heart disease, diabetes, emphysema and many cancers. Cigarette smoke contains more than 7,000 chemicals, and more than 70 are linked to cancer. If e-cigarettes expose users to far fewer of these, why was everyone focused on regulation and not the potential health care savings?
FACT: Far Lower Levels of Harmful Toxins
Unlike cigarette smoke, the liquid in electronic cigarettes consist of four main ingredients: propylene glycol, vegetable glycerin, nicotine and added flavoring. PG and VG are used in foods and cosmetics, but being safe to eat doesn't mean a substance is safe to inhale.
Heating the liquid can also create other compounds, and the aerosol contains metals, likely from the coil. Still, the National Academies found substantial evidence that, apart from nicotine, exposure to toxic substances from e-cigarettes is significantly lower than from cigarettes.
Studies continue to support that e-cigarettes are much less harmful than smoking for adults who switch completely. Their long-term effects aren't yet known, but cutting exposure to so many cancer-causing agents is expected to reduce smoking-related risk.
According to a recent 2013 Tobacco Control Study:
Our findings are consistent with the idea that substituting tobacco cigarettes with e-cigarettes may substantially reduce exposure to selected tobacco-specific toxicants.
* See a complete list of electronic cigarette studies →
Quick to Regulate E-Cigarettes – Despite the Facts
So why is there such a strong push to regulate and tax these devices, which are less harmful than cigarettes and can help smokers quit? Several states including Utah, North Dakota, Arkansas and New Jersey have already passed anti-vaping legislation that limits where e-cigarettes can be used, and countless others such as California and Massachusetts have pending legislation to do the same. In addition, some states are proposing hefty new taxes. Minnesota recently implemented a 95% wholesale tax, making e-cigs subject to higher taxes than regular cigarettes. New York is proposing a similar tax, and several other states are attempting to tax electronic cigarettes just like tobacco.
With such a new and controversial product, it’s understandable that some people are concerned about e-cigs, especially since the public has been overwhelmed with anti-smoking propaganda for years. Some people assume e-cigarettes are as harmful as smoking simply because they look similar, which the evidence doesn't support. There are real concerns, though, especially nicotine addiction and use by young people who never smoked.
We also believed lost tax revenue played a part in the push for new taxes. Governments stand to lose billions in cigarette taxes if smokers switch.
Tax Revenues vs. Health Care Savings
Revenue losses are a legitimate concern for federal and state governments, but what about the long-term impact of encouraging smokers to switch to electronic cigarettes? Couldn’t these entities make up for the lost tax revenue with reduced healthcare expenditures? By over-regulating and taxing electronic cigarettes, we’re not only discouraging electronic cigarette use, but we’ll miss out on a huge opportunity to improve public health and reduce medical costs.
We Could Generate Billions – Without Taxes!
For argument's sake, imagine every US smoker switched completely to electronic cigarettes, and half of smoking's costs went away. Using the 2004 estimate of $193 billion, that's roughly $96.5 billion a year.
By CDC's newer estimate of more than $600 billion in 2018, the potential savings would be far larger. By comparison, CDC says states expected to collect nearly $26 billion in 2024 from tobacco taxes and the 1998 Tobacco Settlement combined.
This is a thought experiment, not a forecast. Not every smoker can switch, and the health effects of long-term vaping are still being studied. But the gap suggests health care savings could far outweigh lost tax revenue. Taxes and strict regulations aren't going to inspire people to switch. With limited access and higher prices, many smokers may stick with cigarettes.
When asked to comment, Dr. Michael Siegel, professor at the Boston University School of Public Health and an expert on smoking and electronic cigarettes, added:
I don’t think there is any question that promoting electronic cigarettes as a tool for smoking cessation would save substantial money on health care expenditures. Smoking is a major contributor to high health care costs and cutting smoking rates would substantially reduce these expenditures. Some financial analysts have predicted that electronic cigarette sales could eventually surpass cigarette sales. If this occurs, it would be a huge public health accomplishment, not only in terms of money saved, but also in terms of lives saved.
Awaiting New FDA Regulations
When this was written, FDA hadn't yet issued rules, and most people expected federal age restrictions to prevent sales to minors, something most of us agreed on. The big debate is whether or not e-cigarettes should be defined as tobacco products, which would open the door to the same strict regulations put on the tobacco industry. Many believe this would essentially kill the electronic cigarette industry as we know it. Rather than having a huge selection of products and a wide variety of low-cost and flexible options – smaller e-cig suppliers would be put out of business and big tobacco companies such as Lorillard, maker of Blu brand e-cigarettes, would dominate the market. Prices would increase dramatically and consumers would lose access to a huge range of products.
Update (October 2026): FDA's deeming rule did classify e-cigarettes as tobacco products, effective August 8, 2016. The federal minimum age to buy them rose to 21 in December 2019, and only FDA-authorized products may now be lawfully sold.
The tide seemed to be turning against the e-cig industry, even though e-cigarettes expose smokers who switch to significantly less risk. We still think policy should weigh the public health benefits and long-term savings of helping adult smokers switch, while keeping these products away from kids.
Vaping products are for adults who smoke or already vape. If you don't smoke, don't start; in the US, the minimum age to buy them is 21.
Sources
- Economic Trends in Tobacco, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
- Chemicals in Cigarettes: From Plant to Product to Puff, U.S. Food and Drug Administration
- Public Health Consequences of E-Cigarettes: Conclusions by Level of Evidence, National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine
- FDA's Deeming Regulations for E-Cigarettes, Cigars, and All Other Tobacco Products, U.S. Food and Drug Administration

