
Despite FDA Regulations, the Vaping Industry Will Survive
Update: This opinion piece was written in May 2016, when the FDA's deeming rule was finalized. Since then, FDA has denied or refused applications for millions of products, only authorized e-cigarettes may be lawfully sold in the US, and the minimum sales age is 21.
The decision to move forward with new FDA regulations has caused widespread doom and gloom in the vaping community. Such a reaction is understandable, and the new rules were sure to cost companies and jobs. We recently discussed some of the potential impacts, but moaning and groaning about how unfair the situation is won’t make things any better. We need to take positive steps to protect the industry and the adult smokers who rely on it.
Few in the vaping community thought the rules, as written, were good for the industry or for public health. At the time, we suggested supporting vaping advocacy groups such as CAASA, Not Blowing Smoke, SFATA and The Right to be Smoke-Free Coalition – who were fighting the rules on behalf of vapers.
We also urged support for HR 2058, which would have moved the grandfather date for vapor products from 2007 to the present, letting more modern devices be sold without FDA authorization. Update: HR 2058 did not become law, and the February 15, 2007 grandfather date still applies.
The FDA Will Not Destroy Vaping
The landscape was set to change drastically when the new vaping regulations took full effect. Even so, here are six reasons we believed vaping would survive:
1. Quality Products Still Available
We were going to lose a lot of vaping products. Estimates at the time ranged up to 80 to 90% of the market disappearing.
Take Mount Baker Vapor as an example. In 2016 it sold at least 90 different flavors of e-juice on their website and most of them are available in various nicotine strengths and PG/VG levels, giving them hundreds of different products. Up until now, they’ve had a huge selection because there was no reason not to offer so much variety, but after the new vaping regulations take effect they’ll be forced to sell only their best products.
Compare this to a company like Coca-Cola. Coca-Cola has literally thousands of different products, but around 90% of their sales come from just three: Coca-Cola, Coke Zero and Diet Coke. Forcing Coca-Cola to sell just those three brands would undoubtedly hinder the company, but it probably wouldn’t go bankrupt.
In a similar fashion, we can imagine that brands like Mount Baker Vapor will continue moving forward with just four or five of their most successful products. Sure, the lack of variety could hurt them (and annoy us!), but they will also benefit from a smaller pool of competitors and it’s even possible that some consumers might be drawn to a simpler and easier-to-understand range of products.
Most importantly, the vaping products left on the market would still be far less harmful than cigarettes for adults who switch completely, so demand would continue.
2. Vaping Innovation Will Continue Elsewhere
The FDA regulations will definitely stifle innovation here in the United States, but that won’t stop it from occurring overseas and elsewhere around the world; especially in China, which has already proven itself capable of producing high quality products, with reputable brands such as Kangertech and Innokin.
Successful products developed abroad could later prove popular enough to justify a US premarket application.
3. Demand Won't Disappear
The people who vape today won't suddenly stop just because their favorite products have been taken off the shelves. Some will look for other sources, which is exactly why unregulated and illicit products are a concern.
Mixing your own e-liquid from nicotine concentrate is risky: liquid nicotine is poisonous if swallowed or spilled on skin, especially for children. Federal law now requires child-resistant packaging for liquid nicotine, and selling homemade e-liquid to others is illegal without FDA authorization.
4. The FDA Faces Some Serious Legal Challenges
In 2016, many in the industry argued that parts of the FDA's rules were contradictory. Here are two examples critics raised.
To regulate e-cigs, the FDA classified them as tobacco products because their nicotine is derived from tobacco. Under the law, sellers also cannot make claims that a product is less harmful, such as "no smoke" claims, without FDA authorization as a modified risk product.
Critics argued that this restricted truthful speech under the First Amendment.
Critics also argued that the FDA treated cigarettes and e-cigarettes differently. In fact, the 2009 Tobacco Control Act requires FDA review before any new tobacco product, including a new cigarette, can be marketed. Older cigarettes already on sale were grandfathered, while nearly all vapor products came after the 2007 cutoff.
We expected an effective legal challenge. The Cole amendment was one proposed way to change the rules, and Nicopure (parent company of Halo Cigs) was the first company to sue the FDA.
Update: That prediction was wrong. The Cole amendment did not become law, and in Nicopure Labs v. FDA (2019), a federal appeals court upheld the deeming rule, including its limits on modified risk claims. The same court rejected similar challenges in 2020.
5. “FDA-Authorized E-Cigs” Could Disarm Critics
The majority of the complaints against e-cigarettes can be summed up in just a few words: “we don’t know enough about them yet”.
The PMTA requires extensive testing of vaping products. The silver lining is that testing produces data that can show whether switching from smoking to vaping benefits adult smokers.
Companies that pass review can sell FDA-authorized products backed by laboratory data. Note that FDA says authorization does not mean a product is safe or “FDA approved.” Products may only be marketed as less risky than cigarettes with a separate modified risk order.
6. Vaping Companies Have Been Preparing
E-cigarettes were always going to become regulated at some point. We might be shocked by how strict and sometimes nonsensical the rules are, but we’re not shocked by the fact that there are rules, or that things are changing.
The smartest companies knew something like this was coming and had been preparing for years, including testing their products ahead of premarket applications.
Stay Calm and Vape On!
This was a frightening time for anyone who worked in the vaping industry or used e-cigarettes to quit smoking. Our advice then still applies: stay calm and stay informed. If you don't smoke, don't start vaping.
Author Bio: Pascal Culverhouse founded the Electric Tobacconist in 2013 and is a passionate industry advocate who vehemently opposes overreaching vaping industry regulation in the United States, and around the world.
Sources
- FDA Makes Determinations On More Than 99% of the 26 Million Tobacco Products For Which Applications Were Submitted, FDA
- Authorized E-Cigarettes, FDA
- Moose Jooce v. FDA (D.C. Cir. 2020), U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
- Liquid Nicotine Packaging, CPSC

