
New FDA Vaping Regulations Now In Place: What Does It Mean?
Update: This is a 2016 news post. Since then, the federal minimum sales age has risen to 21, a court set a September 9, 2020 deadline for premarket applications, and only authorized e-cigarettes may be lawfully sold in the US.
August 8, 2016 has come and gone. That was the date the vaping industry had to start complying with the FDA's deeming rule, which had been debated for some time. While we still believe that the vaping industry will survive the dramatic changes, we’re well aware of the impact online – and at your local vape shop. The rules were set to phase in over several years, but here are some things that changed immediately and what you should expect when shopping for new vaping gear at your favorite retail venue.
Changes at Local Vape Shops
If you haven’t been by your local vape shop since the 8th, your favorite shop may no longer be able to do what it did for you in the past. Here’s what to expect on your next trip:
1.) Have your ID ready. Under the new rules, e-cigarettes are treated like other tobacco products. In 2016 that meant no sales to anyone under 18 and an ID check for anyone under 27, with age verification for online sales too.
Update: Since December 20, 2019, the federal minimum age is 21 for all tobacco products, including e-cigarettes. Since September 30, 2024, retailers must check photo ID for anyone under 30.
The FDA also plans to run undercover checks at both brick-and-mortar and online vapor retailers, so expect to be refused service without ID. Retailers face penalties for underage sales.
2.) No more build help or custom mods. If you’ve had your local shop build your mods for you, replace coils, or do just about any kind of upgrade or maintenance, you’ll now have to do it yourself. Per the new FDA vaping regulations, this is considered to be “manufacturing,” which requires the FDA’s pre-approval process. Most shops can’t afford that.
They can explain how to do it, but you’ll have to do the work yourself. Shop-built custom mods are also likely to disappear.
3.) Samples aren’t free. The rule bans free samples, so retailers can no longer let you try flavors for free. Vaping advocacy groups are suggesting shops charge $1 plus tax for sampling, but the fee will vary from shop to shop.
4.) Less inventory. You may notice that your local vape shop may run low on a lot of products in the immediate future. House juices are still available, but first come first serve and once they’re gone, they’re gone. Most local vape shops won't go through the long and expensive approval process to keep selling in-house juice. Some shops could run low on commercially available juices too, since commercial providers may need time to adjust to the regulations.
There’s also confusion about how the rules affect e-juices in general. Lawsuits over the e-juice portion of the regulations are ongoing, so it could be some time before this issue is fully resolved. Update: In 2019 a federal appeals court upheld the deeming rule in Nicopure Labs v. FDA, and it rejected similar challenges in 2020.
Also expect fewer products on the shelves. New products now need FDA authorization before they can be sold, so releases will slow. Products already on the market by August 8, 2016 can stay for now, but that will change if they don’t gain authorization.
Update: A court order later required applications by September 9, 2020, and FDA has since denied or refused applications for millions of products.
5.) Higher prices. With the cost of the pre-approval process, there is likely to be an increase in price of vaping products. The largest increases will likely occur at smaller manufacturers who don’t have the volume to spread the cost around to a large number of consumers. In some cases, you might find a few manufacturers closing up shop as a result. The market is likely to contract.
6.) Cannot discuss benefits of vaping. Under the law, retailers and manufacturers cannot claim that a product is less harmful than cigarettes unless the FDA has authorized it as a modified risk product. That's despite mounting research that supports e-cigarettes as less harmful than smoking.
A Cochrane review has since found high-certainty evidence that nicotine e-cigarettes help more people quit than nicotine replacement therapy such as patches and gum. No e-cigarette has been FDA-approved as a quit-smoking aid.
Impacts While Shopping Online
The FDA e-cigarette regulations will certainly have a big impact on brick-and-mortar retailers, but online retailers won’t be immune to the changes. As mentioned above, online sellers must verify age, so expect a longer checkout on US websites. And you’ll see similar issues with reduced inventory and higher pricing, since the FDA’s pre-approval process will be costly to manufacturers and limit new product releases.
How will this impact overseas purchases? Since the FDA’s pre-approval process isn’t required in foreign countries, you’re likely to see Chinese websites listing products that aren’t available in the US. Ordering from Chinese and other foreign websites was expected to get harder.
Update: Since October 21, 2021, USPS treats e-cigarettes and vape products as nonmailable for business-to-customer shipments. Unauthorized products may not be lawfully sold in the US.
This is a broad look at a very complicated law, but these are the changes that will have the biggest impact on vapor users. The FDA sometimes clarifies rules after the fact, so check current FDA guidance before relying on this 2016 summary.


