
Are Electronic Cigarettes Safe?

A question that always seems to arise when the subject of e-cigarettes comes up is, “are they safe?” The short answer: no nicotine product is completely safe, but e-cigarettes are far less harmful than smoking for adults who switch completely. Unlike traditional cigarettes, an ‘e-cig’ doesn’t require tobacco smoke to provide a nicotine fix. Instead, it heats up liquid nicotine and turns it into vapor. The vapor looks and feels like tobacco smoke, but it produces no tar or ash. FDA says switching completely may reduce exposure to many harmful chemicals, though e-cigarettes still deliver some harmful chemicals and addictive nicotine.
The Chemical Make-Up
Along with nicotine and added flavoring, the liquid that’s used in most electronic cigarettes is made up of propylene glycol (PG) and / or vegetable glycerin (VG) – chemicals that are used in many of the products that we consume and in the cosmetics that thousands of us wear on our skin. In fact, they’re used in so many consumer products that it would be impossible to list them all.
Propylene glycol is a synthetic compound that is widely used in foods, medicines and cosmetics. Being safe to eat is not the same as being proven safe to inhale for years, though.
Most users report little or no side effects, but dry mouth and throat irritation are common, and some people are sensitive to PG.
In addition to propylene glycol, vegetable glycerin is used by many companies as a base ingredient in their e-liquid. VG is derived from vegetable oils and is also widely used in foods and cosmetics. Since it has slightly different taste and performance qualities, companies may choose to use VG over PG, or combine the two together to take advantage of each of their benefits.
* Learn more about the chemicals inside electronic cigarettes →
New Product With Limited Testing
With all the obvious benefits, common sense may tell you that electronic cigarettes are safe, but the truth is, there’s been no ongoing testing to evaluate the long-term effects of inhaling nicotine vapor. Back in 2009, the FDA analyzed 18 cartridges provided by two popular brands (NJoy and Smoking Everywhere) and found trace amounts of toxic chemicals in several samples. Critics of the analysis said that studies later proved the trace toxins were insignificant next to cigarette smoke, but it did draw attention to the fact that the industry was unregulated and there may be questions about the content of some products. This means choosing reputable suppliers with USP certified ingredients is vital.
Since the FDA findings in 2009, a variety of scientific studies have shown favorable results for electronic cigarettes. A study published by BioMed Central Public Health in 2011 concluded that cigarette smokers could substantially decrease their cigarette consumption without significant side effects by using e-cigarettes, and a 2012 study published by the Society for Research on Nicotine and Tobacco concluded smokers who switched from smoking tobacco to electronic cigarettes reduced their exposure to harmful toxins while maintaining similar levels of nicotine.
In study after study, researchers are finding significantly less chemicals in electronic cigarettes than tobacco. Here is some additional research:
- 2013 Study by Tobacco Control – Toxins in electronic cigarette vapor found to be 9 to 450 times less than tobacco cigarettes and may significantly reduce exposure.
- 2013 Study by Drexel University – Concluded that contaminants measured in e-cigarette liquid and vapor were unlikely to pose a health concern for users.
- 2012 Study by Indoor Air – Compared electronic cigarette vapor to tobacco smoke and found significantly less volatile organic compounds (VOCs).
- 2012 Study by CleanStream Air – Evaluated the effect of second-hand vapor and found no detectable amounts of toxic substances or carcinogens.
- 2012 Study by Inhalation Toxicology – Found no apparent risk to human health from the indoor air emissions it measured.
* See a complete list of UP-TO-DATE e-cigarette studies →
Some Are Calling for More Oversight
When this post was written, electronic cigarettes were unregulated in the United States, and there was mounting pressure to regulate the industry – requiring more testing and additional oversight. Studies seem to suggest that there are very few risks, but it will take years of additional research to understand the long-term impacts of inhaling vaporized nicotine. (UPDATE ON THE LATEST VAPING REGULATIONS)
Update: FDA has regulated e-cigarettes as tobacco products since its deeming rule took effect on August 8, 2016. Only FDA-authorized e-cigarettes may be lawfully sold in the US, and authorization doesn’t mean a product is safe or FDA approved.
The federal minimum age to buy e-cigarettes is 21.
With their recent introduction in 2007, electronic cigarettes are a new and controversial product that are sure to keep sparking debate. No one is 100% sure about the long-term effects, but from our perspective, e-cigarettes are a much safer option than smoking tobacco. By cutting exposure to most of the carcinogens in cigarette smoke, it stands to reason that any potential side effects of e-cigarettes are much less severe than smoking. Are e-cigarettes safe? Maybe the question should be… are they safer than smoking? For adults who switch completely, the evidence says yes: the NHS says vaping poses a small fraction of the risk of smoking.
If you don’t smoke, don’t start vaping.


